The Law Office of Patrick T. Donovan

Massachusetts Criminal Attorney

617.479.1800 24/7
  • Home
  • Profile
  • Criminal Defense
    • Restraining Orders
      • Restraining Orders FAQs
    • Harassment Orders
    • Domestic Violence
      • Domestic Violence Case Wins
      • Assault and Battery on Family or Household Member
      • Restraining Order Violation
      • Assault on Family Member
      • Witness Intimidation
      • Strangulation Suffocation
      • Stalking
      • Threats to Commit a Crime
      • Mass Law About Hitting Your Kids
    • Drunk Driving
      • OUI DUI WINS
      • First Offense
      • How Much Does an OUI Cost?
      • CHILD ENDANGERMENT WHILE OUI
    • Motor Vehicle
      • Motor Vehicle Crime Case Wins
      • LEAVING THE SCENE OF PERSONAL INJURY
      • LEAVING THE SCENE OF PROPERTY DAMAGE
      • OPERATING AFTER LICENSE SUSPENDED
      • NEGLIGENT OPERATION
      • Reckless Operation
      • Uninsured Motor Vehicle
      • MASSACHUSETTS UNLICENSED OPERATION
      • Attaching Wrong Plates Massachusetts
      • Massachusetts Road Racing
      • Failure to Obey Police Officer
      • Use of Motor Vehicle Without Authority
      • IGNITION INTERLOCK DEVICE
    • Encore Boston Harbor Criminal Attorney
    • Theft Crimes
      • Theft Crimes Wins
      • LARCENY UNDER $1200
      • Larceny Over $1200 in Massachusetts
      • LARCENY BY CHECK
      • Identity Fraud
      • Larceny By Embezzlement
      • Credit Card Fraud
      • Receiving Stolen Property
    • Drug Crimes
    • Sex Crimes
      • Statutory Rape
      • OPEN AND GROSS LEWDNESS AND LASCIVIOUS BEHAVIOR
      • Annoying and Accosting Persons
      • Indecent Assault and Battery
      • Indecent Exposure
      • Enticing a Child Under 16
    • College Students
      • Fake ID
      • Fake ID Case Wins
      • Disorderly Conduct
      • MINOR IN POSSESSION OF ALCOHOL MASSACHUSETTS
      • Disturbing the Peace
    • Criminal Harassment
    • Violent Crime
      • Assault and Battery Wins
      • Threats
      • Aggravated Assault and Battery
      • Mayhem
      • Assault and Battery with a Dangerous Weapon
      • Assault and Battery
        • Shoplifting
          • Shoplifting Case Wins
      • Assault
      • Resisting Arrest
    • Clerk’s Hearings
    • Weapons Crimes
    • Warrants
    • Speeding Tickets
      • Massachusetts Surchargeable Infractions
      • Massachusetts Speeding Ticket Recent Victories
      • How to Appeal a Massachusetts Speeding Ticket
      • Massachusetts RMV and Board of Appeals
      • Massachusetts Speeding Tickets FAQ
      • Massachusetts Drivers Suspensions
  • Case Wins
  • Client Reviews
  • Contact Us

Qualified Immunity

June 23, 2020 by Patrick Donovan

Qualified Immunity 

Qualified immunity police officers from being held personally liable for constitutional violations as long as the official did not violate “clearly established” law. 

In 1871, Congress  passed 42 USC 1983 to allow citizens to sue government officials personally for civil rights violations. 

It says, “Every person who under color of any statute…subjects any person to the deprivation of any rights, privileges or immunities secured by the Constitution shall be liable to the party injured in any action at law.

Meaning you can sue anyone from the government to who violates your constitutional rights. 

However in 1983 the Supreme Court established “qualified immunity.” 

The Court said unless a police officer violated a “Clearly Established” legal right they could not be sued. 

Saying would be unfair to hold government officials to constitutional rules they were not aware of at the time of the violation. 

A ”Clearly Established” is so obvious and well known that any reasonable police officer would have known. 

And it must be so clear to the least informed, least reasonable ‘reasonable officer.

The Supreme Court said that qualified immunity protects “all but the plainly incompetent or those who knowingly violate the law.”

Judges must apply a two part test before accepting a “qualified immunity” defense.  

First,  If the allegations are true are they really a violation of your rights? 

Second, were those rights clearly established? 

So unless there is a case directly on point qualified immunity applies meaning “ No precedent = no clearly established law = no liability.”

Categories: Legal News

Just Arrested?

Everything you need to know if you were arrested in Massachusetts.

Arrest Information

Court Process

Everything you need to know about the Massachusetts Court Process

Court Process Explained

Criminal Record

See how a criminal case impacts your criminal record.

Info about Criminal Records

Practice Areas

  • Criminal Defense
  • Drunk Driving
  • Domestic Violence
  • Motor Vehicle
  • Drug Crimes
  • Sex Crimes
  • College Students
  • Disturbing the Peace
  • Criminal Harassment
  • Theft Crimes
  • Violent Crimes
  • Disorderly Conduct
  • Warrants
  • Record Sealing
  • Probation
  • Weapons Crimes
  • Magistrate Hearing
  • Personal Injury
  • Speeding Tickets

Menu

  • Criminal Defense
  • Drunk Driving
  • Domestic Violence
  • Motor Vehicle Crimes
  • Drug Crimes
  • Sex Crimes
  • Theft
  • Contact Us
  • Make a Payment

Office Location

Law Office of Patrick Donovan
Law Office of Patrick Donovan logo
234 Copeland Street Suite 230
Quincy, MA 02169
Phone: (617) 479-1800
Fax: (617) 622-1531

Court Information

Everything you need to know about criminal courts in Massachusetts.

Court Info

Copyright © 2023