An emergency restraining order is a civil order with criminal penalties. It is issued by a Massachusetts judge for up to 10 days. Emergency restraining orders are issued after a one-sided hearing (called ex-parte). An emergency restraining order can be issued by a judge over the phone. It is only valid until the court opens for normal business.
Judges can only issue a restraining order, or 209a order, where the plaintiff and defendant:
– were married to one another:
– are living or did live in the same household;
– are or were related by blood or marriage;
– have a child together,
– are or have been in a substantive dating or engagement relationship.
If the parties do not have a relationship outlined above, a judge cannot issue a 209a restraining order. However, there is no relationship requirement for 258e Harassment Order.
Abuse is defined as
(a) attempting to cause or causing physical harm;
(b) placing another in fear of imminent serious physical harm;
(c) causing another to engage involuntarily in sexual relations by force, threat, or duress.
If the judge does not find that abuse has taken place he or she cannot issue the restraining order.
If a judge grants a restraining order it may order the defendant not to abuse the plaintiff. It may also order the defendant to stay away from the plaintiff.
1) tell the defendant not to contact and stay away from the plaintiff;
order the defendant to vacate immediately and remain away from the house, or workplace;
2) Award the plaintiff temporary custody of a minor child;
order the defendant to pay temporary child support;
3) Make the defendant pay compensation for losses suffered as a result of the abuse;
4) order information be impounded;
order the defendant to refrain from abusing or contacting the plaintiff’s child;
5) recommend to the defendant that the defendant attend a batterer intervention.
Also, anyone who owns firearms must turn them over to their local police department.
A mutual restraining order is where both sides seek a restraining order. In only rare cases will a Judge in Massachusetts issue a mutual restraining order. In the case where a Judge issues mutual restraining orders, they are required to make written findings. Mutual restraining orders are issued when both parties can convince a judge that they have suffered abuse, and both need an order of protection.
Restraining order hearings are held in front of a judge. The courtroom is open to the public. People may be there.
At the hearing, the person seeking the order is called the Plaintiff. The plaintiff has the burden of proof. That means they must convince a judge by a preponderance of the evidence that they are in fear of abuse.
Both sides may offer testimony and evidence. Either side may call witnesses and cross-examine one another. Judges will issue their ruling at the end of the hearing. A judge may either issue the order for up to one year or they may decline to issue the order.
The burden of proof is on the plaintiff to prove by a preponderance of the evidence that they need an abuse prevention order.
A judge must find that the person seeking a restraining order has shown by a preponderance of the evidence that an extension of the order is necessary to protect him or her from the likelihood of ‘abuse’ as defined in G.L. c. 209A. In Massachusetts, a restraining order is a civil order with criminal penalties. Because it is a civil order a judge must use the civil standard in issuing a restraining order. The civil standard is proof by a preponderance of the evidence. Proof by a preponderance of the evidence is a standard less than proof beyond a reasonable doubt.
The Massachusetts rules of evidence are relaxed in restraining order hearings. The civil rules of evidence relating to hearsay, best evidence, or authenticity are flexibly applied in restraining order hearings. Judges are encouraged to consider fundamental fairness in making a decision relating to evidence.
Yes. Both the parties may ask questions. Cross-examination is allowed as long as it is not being done to harass or intimidate the other side.
A Defendant forfeits their day in court if they fail to appear. Judges will hold the hearing and issue the order if the plaintiff meets their burden of proof.
Unlike in a criminal case if the Defendant does not testify the Judge may hold that against him or her.
If the Plaintiff does not appear the Massachusetts restraining order will expire at the date listed on the Order. If there is a reason the Plaintiff did not appear then the Judge could continue the hearing until a later date, no later than 10 days. Any decision to reschedule the case is made by the Judge.
At the first two-party hearing a Massachusetts may issue a restraining order for up to one year. It can be for less time if the plaintiff requests a shorter period or if the judge sees a reason to make it less than one year.
Yes, a restraining order can be permanent after one year. At the first hearing, a judge may issue the Massachusetts 209A Order for up to one year. After one year there is another hearing scheduled. At the one-year hearing, a judge may make the restraining order permanent.
You can appeal a 209a order to the Appeals Court. There is nothing in the restraining order law that allows for an appeal after a hearing.
A Massachusetts restraining order can be permanent. At the first hearing, it can be extended for up to one year. At the renewal hearing, a judge may make the order lifetime.
Massachusetts Restraining Order Resources
Massachusetts Restraining Order Attorney Patrick Donovan
Patrick Donovan is a former Massachusetts prosecutor who has appeared in over fifty Massachusetts courts. Attorney Donovan has helped many people successfully defend themselves against 209a orders.
